Thursday, September 03, 2026

A moral and evolutionary necessity

 Collated by Tusar Nath Mohapatra

Vedic Unity: Taadatmya तादात्म्य 

तादात्म्य is made of two words तत् and आत्म्य 

It means having that or tat as one’s self or atma. The lover becomes one with the beloved, the bhakta with the Ishvara, the dhyani with the universe

We may say that it is not specifically mentioned in the Rig Veda. But we see instances of it throughout the Veda, in the Devi Suktam, the Purusha Suktam and in the famous realization Ekam Sat Vipra Bahudha Vedanti (RV 1.164.46)

But, it is obvious that this identity or oneness or essential unity एकत्व or तादात्म्य is the foundation of the Rig Veda and may be experienced right from the first rik of the Veda 

If we realize this then tadatmya तादात्म्य is not felt only at the end but right from the beginning through and through to the end 

It is the central motif of the Veda and that is the true adhyatmik dimension of the Veda 

https://x.com/AmazingVedas/status/2095364270502416827

Veda as Vedanta Living and Singing

Let me try a Vedantic example to show how the adhyatmik emerges out of the beautiful poetry of the Veda

This is a thought experiment 

Imagine you are the water in the body of the ocean. How do you see a wave? Or shall we say, you yourself as a wave?

Language collapses, doesn’t it? Now only poetry or music can describe the experience of the water that is you. It is you but you have taken a particular form and movement, आकार-गति 

Are you with me so far? There is no difference between the water and the wave except that the water has taken a unique appearance within the body of the water

Thus, the adhyatmik insight no longer separates the seer and the seen, the knower and known. The seer is the seen. The knower is the known. Agni and Mitra are all the unfolding of a Reality that is One. Does this make sense? 

https://x.com/AmazingVedas/status/2095020697399501115

Bhubaneswar, Odisha: On how Indian philosophy should be incorporated into education today, Gitanjali Angmo, wife of Activist Sonam Wangchuk, says, "I teach the Vedas, Upanishads, and the Gita in the light of Sri Aurobindo, so I don't say this lightly. If we go into the depth of these texts—like Nyaya and Vaisheshika—they talk about reality and logic. Where do children learn about our nine systems of philosophy? They should learn them, shouldn't they? If we study logic, why don't we study Nyaya? If we study quantum physics, why not Vaisheshika? If we study philosophy, why not Advaita Vedanta? Why do we only read Western philosophers? These are some of the issues that I think are essential in education system reform. Only then can we defeat this polarization and mindset—if every child, from kindergarten onwards, understands and assimilates all philosophies, and then chooses which philosophy to follow..."

https://x.com/ians_india/status/2095362057428418757

The Unslayable Cow: Symbol of Wealth, Rays of Light & Infinite Consciousness. With Richard Hartz explore Sri Aurobindo’s hidden meaning in the Vedas. Watch youtu.be/HYlQnQcE5Ak?si… @MakrandParanspe @PariksithSingh @AmazingVedas

https://x.com/sriaurobindochr/status/2095255946478157844

What did Sri Aurobindo discover in Vamadeva’s hymns? Explore his mystical interpretation of the Rig Veda’s Fourth Mandala & its profound symbolism, hidden meanings, & vision of consciousness with Richard Hartz youtu.be/MLzVIYJF3mA?si… @MakrandParanspe @PariksithSingh @AmazingVedas

https://x.com/sriaurobindochr/status/2095210899674116440

What if the Vedas hide a deeper truth? In discussion with @MakrandParanspe, Richard Hartz explores Sri Aurobindo’s The Secret of the Veda—and how symbolism unlocks meanings beyond the literal. youtu.be/C5uOoXuvz9A?si… @PariksithSingh @AmazingVedas

https://x.com/sriaurobindochr/status/2095134899011522681

Poetic Influences on the Development of Aurobindo's Spiritual and Nationalistic Convictions

ET Ulrich - International Journal of Hindu Studies, 2010 - JSTOR
… It was a dramatic step for Aurobindo to go from agnosticism … the idea that Brahman is the true reality. Many scholars believe … Aurobindo wrote and spoke with religious fervor, predicting

Sri Aurobindo's evolutionary ontology of consciousness

M Cornelissen - Consciousness, Indian psychology and yoga, 2004 - researchgate.net
… tremendous individual effort, he predicts that eventually the supramental … In this chapter a comparison is drawn between Sri Aurobindo’… , what Sri Aurobindo calls the “supramental Truth-…

Sri Aurobindo’s evolutionary ontology of consciousness

Matthijs Cornelissen

Consciousness, Indian psychology and yoga, 11-52, 2004

Sri Aurobindo sees evolution primarily as an ongoing evolution of consciousness. He holds that the human mind is much too imperfect a type of consciousness to be the final resting point of nature, and that just as life developed out of matter, and mind out of life, a still higher form of consciousness is bound to develop out of the mind. For his evolutionary ontology of consciousness, Sri Aurobindo bases himself on the Vedântic view of consciousness, which says that consciousness is pervasive throughout reality and that it manifests as a range of ever higher gradations of consciousness and being. In matter, consciousness is fully engrossed in its own existence and shows itself only as matter’s habit of form and its tendency to obey fixed laws. In plant and animal life, consciousness begins to emancipate a little, there are the first signs of exchange, of giving and taking, of feelings, drives and emotions. In the human mind we see a further emancipation of consciousness in the first appearance of an ability to “play with ideas in one’s mind” and to rise above the immediate situation. The mind is characteristically the plane of objective, generalized statements, ideas, thoughts, intelligence, etc. But the mind is also an inveterate divider, making distinctions between subject and object, I and thou, things and other things.

Within the Vedic tradition, the ordinary human mentality is considered to be only the most primitive form of mental consciousness, most ego-bound, most dependent on the physical senses. Above it there is the unitary Higher Mind of self-revealed wisdom, the Illumined Mind where truths are seen rather than thought, the plane of the Intuitive Mind where truth is inevitable and perfect, and finally the cosmic Overmind, the mind of the Gods, comprehensive, allencompassing. But in all these mental planes, however far beyond our ordinary mentality, there is still a trace of division, the possibility of discord and disharmony. One has to rise beyond all of them to find a truly Gnostic consciousness, intrinsically harmonious, perfect, one with the divine consciousness that upholds the universe. Many spiritual traditions have claimed that it is possible to connect or even merge with an absolute consciousness beyond mind, but, according to Sri Aurobindo, it is at this moment... 

Sri Aurobindo as a Critic

KD Verma - The Indian Imagination: Critical Essays on Indian …, 2000 - Springer
… But Aurobindo concedes that "there is a truth in the historical theory of criticism," perhaps for ascertaining "our intellectual judgment of a poet and his work" (FP 39). Thus both the poet …

Indeed, Aurobindo is mostly known as a philosopher and a poet, but his stature as critic remains somewhat unassessed—and deeply undervalued—and perhaps overshadowed by the unsurpassed brilliance and originality of his work in other areas.2 Whatever the merits of the three long essays in Significance of Indian Art, this volatile document shows Aurobindo’s successful attempt to offer his interpretation of Indian art based on his theory of the expansion of consciousness and the Indian idea of rasa-bhava-ananda, derived from Bharata’s Natya Shastra.3 Aurobindo has used these ideas in The Future Poetry (1917–20) on a larger scale, but this time the subject is the English language and literature, especially poetry. One must say unhesitatingly that The Future Poetry is an important and unique document in literary history and critical theory. In the introductory essay, Aurobindo straightforwardly and candidly refers to his reading of James Cousins’s New Ways in English Literature, that possibly provided the imrnediate context to a series of essays in the Arya.4 Aurobindo admits that since his “departure from England quarter of a century ago” all connections with contemporary English literature had come to “a dead stop” and that he had kept abreast only with contemporary continental literature. His last discovery of a poet in English literature, states Aurobindo, was Meredith.5

Aurobindonian Rhetoric and the Problem of Evaluation

D Goswami - The Criterion: An International Journal In English - the-criterion.com
… is: Sri Aurobindo followed a completely different poetic tradition for his creative expression than that practised by the modernists. It is true that Sri Aurobindo … , Lal randomly picks up a few …

During the post-independence era, Indian poets writing in English showed serious issues with Sri Aurobindo’s spiritual poetry; particularly its language. They felt that the language he used in his poetry did not qualify as poetic. However, their dismissal of Sri Aurobindo as a poet took the form of scathing, virulent criticisms; by means of which they attempted to mould the aesthetic taste of the budding generation of poets in India. In this paper, I attempt to discuss the problems as well as possibilities involved in interpreting poetry in general and in appreciating Aurobindonian poetry in particular. The paper does not intend to blindly justify Aurobindonian rhetoric. However, it does provide an insight into the ideational models which led Sri Aurobindo to create his unique body of poetry. In so doing, the paper tries to explore the possibilities of aesthetic tolerance which might enable Sri Aurobindo’s poetry to reach out and speak for its own; instead of being written off and pushed into oblivion by the systemic politics practised by the first generation of modern Indian English poets.

Sri Aurobindo As a Dramatist: A Critical Exploration

P Kumari - Integral Research, 2025 - integralresearch.in
… He picks up the Greek myth and reinvents it … , yet the real message behind it is the aspect of fate, freedom and the quest of soul after higher truth, a great example of how Sri Aurobindo
Sri Aurobindo has frequently been mentioned as among the most significant modern Indian philosophers, poets, and thinkers, and he did not confine himself to poetry or philosophy, as he also entered the fields of drama. His plays combine both the elements of spirituality and the classical form binding myth, history, and philosophy together. He always represents the conflict between human restraint and Godliness. Although his plays are not often staged, there is genuine interest in the fate of humanity and development of awareness. In this paper, a close look at the dramatic output of Sri Aurobindo will be made, and the ways in which his plays reflect his vision of life and literature at large. It identifies his symbolism, blending of western and Indian cultures and his aim to create a theatre of ideas that goes beyond entertainment to create spiritual awakening.

Ethical skepticism in the philosophy of Sri Aurobindo

S Phillips - Indian Ethics: Classical Traditions and Contemporary …, 2017 - books.google.com
… Nor, I admit, is it strictly correct, for Aurobindo does not hold … conflict with Aurobindo’s stated skepticism than that Aurobindo was … The deep questions with Aurobindo concern the value of

Ethical skepticism in the philosophy of Sri Aurobindo

Stephen Phillips

Indian Ethics: Classical Traditions and Contemporary Challenges: Volume I 1, 48, 2017

Sri Aurobindo Ghose (1872-1950), a yogin and spiritual teacher as well as a nationalist politician of prominence, wrote widely. With a career that began as a speechwriter and journalist, Aurobindo became a philosopher and poet after varied efforts as newspaper editor and polemicist urging the end of British rule. In his forties, he dropped out of politics to give, by his own account, his entire attention to yoga. As a philosopher, Aurobindo advocates a mystical summum bonum along the lines of the classical schools of Yoga and Vedānta. But he adds a rather original cosmology, claiming sensitivity to science. He puts forth a metaphysics best classified as a modern Vedāntic theism or neo-Vedānta.

Aurobindo's ethical teaching is not, however, what one might expect from a modern guru in the neo-Vedāntic mold. He does not subscribe to a divine command theory. He recognizes no scripture or'śāstra'as valid. Moreover, Aurobindo is no deontologist, no upholder of general duties, except in a slim sense that I shall try to explain. Nor does he endorse a teleological ethics, although it would be legitimate to say that, according to him, actions and practices do, for certain people at certain times, derive their worth in relation to a supreme good. This would be mystical experience of the one, Brahman, and spiritual transformation by Brahman's 'Shakti,' bringing about a spiritual life. And while it is possible to read Aurobindo as a hedonist-pleasure as a form of ānanda, Brahman's nature as 'bliss,' motivating in various forms all action his hedonism is strictly a psychological thesis, not an ethical theory. Aurobindo expressly denies an ethics of general utility, despite his psychological hedonism. He argues that pleasure, to include the bliss of mystical experience, typically trumps morality in life and action, moral injunctions being social and practical expediencies.

The Philosophy of Sri Aurobindo: Its Epistemological and Conceptive Significance

R Trivedi - East and West, 1971 - JSTOR
… The world, we inhabit, is the actualization of one such Truth-… and self-finding ?, according to Sri Aurobindo, ? is one of the … istence ?, says Sri Aurobindo, ? is the ecstatic dance of Shiva …

The Philosophy of Sri Aurobindo: Its Epistemological and Conceptive Significance

Ramchandra Trivedi

East and West 21 (1/2), 137-154, 1971

Sri Aurobindo, a recent Indian mystico-philosopher has propounded, for the first time in the history of Vedantism, a full-fledged philosophy of the world (1). Combining the modern evolutionary thought with the supramental experience of All is Brahman, which forms the basis or the standpoint of his philosophy, he conceives the whole scheme of the world, or, to speak in his language, the Divine Plan of the World. In this scheme or the Divine Plan of the world he seeks to answer the agelong philosophical questions about the nature of the world, viz., how has the world been created, why has it been created and where lies its destination. If we make a philosophical analysis of the conceptions constituting the answers to these questions, we find that these conceptions possess metaphysical significances on account of their epistemological or supramental significances, and that their metaphysical significances have conceptive significances and not objective significances. Accor i1) 

It may be noted that the old vedantic philosophers, whether of the Upanisads or those who followed the upanisadic line of thinking, were not so much interested in speaking about the how, why and wherefore of the evolution of the universe as they were interested in showing the ultimate reality of it and the ways and means to realize that reality. Gaudapada and Samkara, the two great acaryas of the advaitic line of vedantic philosophy, even went to the extent of saying that the only purpose of the sruti passages dealing with the creation of the universe is not to explain the how, why and wherefore of the universe but to direct our attention beyond the fact of creation of the world to the knowledge of Brahman, because it is this knowledge which alone will carry us beyond the samsara (see Gaudapada-Karika, 3, 15 and Samkara's Commentary on Brahma-Sutras, 2, 1.27). Even, among all the upanisadic theories of creation, the commonly accepted theory of creation only says, as we know, that the universe originates from Brahman and dissolves into Brahman, and that the processes of origination and dissolution of the universe constitute, respectively, the process of successive origination of the physical principles of ether, air, fire, water and earth from Brahman and the process of successive dissolution of them in the reverse order of it into Brahman. It, thus, speaks neither about the evolution of the principles of Life and Mind in the universe, nor about the destination of the universe.

In the context of the present evolutionary thinking, the theory, therefore, remains incomplete and unsatisfactory. Dominated by the practical aim of realization of the spiritual Reality of Existence, no systematic thinking was, therefore, done by the vedantic philosophers to propound a full-fledged philosophy of the universe. It is to the credit of Sri Aurobindo that he, being a product of the modern age of evolutionary thinking, realized this lacuna in the vedantic philosophy and fullfilled it by propounding a full-fledged philosophy of the universe. Combining the practical and philosophical interests, he looks at philosophy not as a means of realizing the Reality of the Existence alone but also as a means of realizing the spiritual and supramental transformation of the human-existence itself upon the earth, ie, to realize The Life Divine or The Divine Life upon Earth. Philosophy, in its true sense, is not only a discovery of the reality of Existence and the discovery of the ways and means to realize that Reality, but is also a discovery of the how, why and wherefore of the evolution of the universe. And, therefore, it is in the philosophy of Sri Aurobindo that the vedantic philosophy, especially the philosophy of …

From the self to the Self: An exposition on personality based on the works of Sri Aurobindo

S Aurobindo - academia.edu
… It theoretical goal is the prediction and control of behavior… The behaviorist in his efforts to … with the body/essence of truth and for this reason Sri Aurobindo has used the term revelatory …

Having undergone many twists and turns in my life, many ups and downs, I have often wondered whether crucial events in my life which have been turning points, occurred merely by chance or accident or there was and continues to be a deeper meaning, some sort of a design which existed from the time of my birth, and which the course of my life has been following. For many years, I held the view that significant life events occurred due to chance factors–what I perceived as a crisis, I attempted to account for on the basis of external considerations. But for some time now I have been getting more and more convinced that these turning points in my life were so because of the workings of an inner being within the core of my existence, self or personality. It is this entity located deep within myself which has always been guiding me, and making me react and experience in ways which eventually lead to my growth.

MYSTICISM AND THE FUTURE: THE RELEVANCE OF SRI AUROBINDO'S VISION IN A GLOBAL YOGIC AGE

P SAMATA - International Journal of Multidisciplinary Researches - rootsjournal.com
… The next step in evolution, he predicts, is the emergence of the supramental being —a … discourse dreams of technological immortality, Aurobindo reminds us that true evolution lies not in... 
Aurobindo’s mysticism transcends the ascetic withdrawal of traditional yoga and envisions a spiritual humanism rooted in transformation rather than renunciation. By positioning his work within the discourse of contemporary consciousness studies, ecology, and posthumanism, this paper argues that Aurobindo’s integral mysticism holds renewed relevance for the twenty-first century. His poetry and prose are not mere relics of Indian spiritual romanticism; they form the groundwork of a global paradigm that bridges East and West, science and spirit, intellect and intuition. In our age of artificial intelligence and ecological anxiety, his call for the divinization of life emerges as both a moral and evolutionary necessity. Sri Aurobindo’s mysticism is thus not the past’s echo but the prophecy of the future—a supramental vision that continues to inspire the world’s ongoing quest for unity, consciousness, and divine love.

[PDF] Ambedkar as a global anti-caste thinker: Dialogues with Du Bois, Fanon and contemporary critical race theory

DP Mitra
This paper takes up a problem that global social theory has quietly lived with for
decades: caste remains pushed to the margins of race theory treated as local,
cultural or residual even though it works through structure, inheritance and social …

[PDF] Dalit Assertion in Manohar Mouli Biswas's Surviving in My World: Growing Up Dalit in Bengal

P Jain - 2025
This paper explores the transformative journey from systemic oppression to vocal
assertion of Dalit identity and resistance against entrenched systems of caste-based
oppression as depicted in Surviving in My World: Growing Up Dalit in Bengal by …

Re-caste-ing Dalit Women in Brahmanical Environmentalism: A Case Study of Sulabh and 'Liberated' Scavengers

M Sharma - Journal of South Asian Development, 2025
This article provides a gendered, anti-caste critique of Sulabh International’s widely
celebrated rehabilitation model for Dalit women manual scavengers, situating it
within the broader field of environmental politics. While Sulabh has demonstrably …

[HTML] 'Lonely People Meet': Sayantan Ghosh's debut loses its way in philosophy and alternate reality

D Sengupta - 2025
… Karno’s political views seemed irrelevant to the plot, yet his reaction to a
Deendayal Upadhyaya statue halfway through the novel – seeing him as a Hindutva
sympathiser – makes his already unclear character even more confusing. …

Decolonisation without decoloniality: trends of statue politics in postcolonial India, 1947–2023

A Ghosh - Contemporary South Asia, 2025
… Consequently, while Hindutva and Caste politics have both addressed the matter
of spatial ‘decolonisation’ along their fault lines, they have consistently adhered to a
colonial worldview and have misunderstood decolonisation through the lens of …

Communal Geographies

S Legg, W Gould, C Gupta
This book combines two special issues published earlier in the journal South Asia.
Comprising fifteen papers, it delves into complex geographies and spatialities of
communal identities in modern South Asia, with a special focus on the years leading …

[PDF] The Influence of Islamic Environment Buddhism and Hinduism in Multan

MADM Ashraf - PAYAM (Research Journal of Iqbal Studies), 2025
… (6) Ricard Eaton exposes the British and Hindutva manipulation of history by
portraying Indian Muslims as villains … Ricard Eaton exposes the British and
Hindutva manipulation of history by portraying Indian Muslims as villains) …

[PDF] Governing Religion: Colonial Legality, State, and the Case of Hijab in India

TJ Kiliyamannil - Muslim Politics Review, 2025
In March 2022, India’s Karnataka High Court ruled that the wearing of hijab by
Muslim students was not an ‘essential religious practice’under Islam. This raised a
question of authority to interpret Islamic law, as the judges effectively decided what …

Sudha Murty's Short Stories as Catalysts in Redefining Masculine Perceptions of Women's Roles, Female Identity and Social Agency in Contemporary Indian Society

AP Shahina Mumthaz, J Sheila - International Journal of …, 2026 - internationalsped.com
… In Ganga’s Ghat, the eponymous character is a village coolie whose social status is undermined by her profession and gender. But her selfless act of providing water to underprivileged …

The Curious Case of Dadagiri: Masculinities and Everyday Power in the Ghats of Kolkata

R Ghosh - Journal für Entwicklungspolitik, 2025 - jep-journal.com
… ), this paper showcases how masculinity takes the form of the … ghats (steps leading down to the river) of the River Hooghly in Kolkata, I arrive at two distinct tropes of tactical masculinity

[HTML] Part of a series on Masculism

SI Family, SOS Papa, R Bly
Masculism or masculinism [1] may variously refer to ideologies and socio-political
movements that seek to eliminate sexism against men, equalize their rights with
women,[1][2] and increase adherence to or promotion of attributes regarded as …

[HTML] Political quietism in Islam

A al-Bayt
In the political aspects of Islam, political quietism in Islam is the religiously-motivated
withdrawal from political affairs or skepticism that mere mortals can establish a true
Islamic government. It is the opposite of political Islam, which holds that the Islamic …

Saturday, August 29, 2026

Who is the best person for the job?

 Collated by Tusar Nath Mohapatra

The Mother of Swords: How the 2026 Act Chose Bankim’s Nationalism Over Tagore’s Patriotism

by Skand Priya countercurrents.org/2026/08/the-mo…

The 2026 National Honour (Amendment) Act has brought “Vande Mataram” into a new legal and political framework, extending penal protections to the National Song. This article examines the historical and ideological differences between Bankimchandra Chattopadhyay’s “Vande Mataram” and Rabindranath Tagore’s “Jana Gana Mana,” drawing on the distinction between nationalism and patriotism developed by Tagore. It traces the constitutional compromise of 1950, the later political recovery of the song’s militant stanzas, and the implications of making national honour a matter of law. The article argues that the Act marks a shift from voluntary patriotic sentiment toward a more assertive and coercive conception of nationalism.

https://x.com/Countercurrents/status/2093216946494009646

Discover Sarasvati—the sacred river, goddess, & eternal stream of wisdom. In this inspiring episode of Amazing Vedas, @PariksithSingh & @MakrandParanspe explore her timeless connection to knowledge, creativity, & spiritual awakening. Watch youtu.be/snGDC4QqJFo?si… @AmazingVedas

https://x.com/sriaurobindochr/status/2093323463138394172

How can ancient Vedic sciences help us understand our patterns? Explore Smt. Radhe Pfau’s journey into Vedic astrology and discover insights into self-understanding, patterns, and spiritual growth. youtu.be/yKCWEYb3GIg?si… @MakrandParanspe @PariksithSingh @AmazingVedas

https://x.com/sriaurobindochr/status/2093441993749741612

The Psychic Being Exists in a Fourth Dimension Outside the Three Spatial Dimensions sriaurobindostudies.wordpress.com/2026/08/28/the… via @santoshk1

https://x.com/santoshk1/status/2093453957876367823

Is there one definitive reality, or do we live trapped in our own minds? Philosopher Hilary Lawson argues that there is no objective truth; what we believe to be real is shaped by a series of mental conclusions, or "closures," that each of us makes for ourselves. To reason with conspiracy theorists, then, we must not appeal to "the truth," but learn to use their own logic against them. Join Hilary Lawson and Slavoj Žižek as they question the very foundations of reality. iai.tv/video/beyond-t…

https://x.com/IAI_TV/status/2093338321783001132

A system built on truth asks: who is the best person for the job? That question is lethal to inherited position – merit doesn’t check your surname... The large corporations are run exactly like socialism from the inside: committees instead of owners, process instead of judgment, HR as the party cell, DEI statements as the loyalty oath, promotion by narrative compliance – and the shareholders as distant and powerless as the Soviet “people” who nominally owned everything. The managerial class holds them the way the nomenklatura held the state enterprises: legally owning nothing, actually controlling everything, and answering for no result.

https://x.com/Kristof_Poland/status/2093249180072370191

“As Roger Griffin notes, many on the European New Right have drawn a theory of history from Julius Evola, choosing to view themselves as dwelling in the apocalyptic Kali Yuga on the threshold of a new golden age of history. As Nicholas Goodrick-Clark notes, in the post-war period, Evola’s ideas became a sophisticated alternative to crude Anglo-American neo-Nazism in which Nazi creed became reformulated as white supremacist ideology.”

https://x.com/scroll_in/status/2093273634630521336

To notice is not always a deliberate moral decision. Attraction may arise without invitation, and a thought may appear without being consciously chosen. But this is precisely where Dharma begins... Noticing is not the same as staring. Feeling attracted is not the same as believing we are entitled to another person. An involuntary response is not the same as a deliberate choice. An involuntary reaction does not justify a deliberate violation of another person’s dignity. The presence of stimulus does not remove individual responsibility. If anything, Dharma places responsibility firmly upon the individual.

https://x.com/Pragyata_/status/2093295590432182598

For an act of resistance to the tyranny of algorithms, try the Marginalian newsletter — undistracted notes on the search for meaning through art, science, philosophy, poetry, and various other tendrils of wonder. For 20 years, it has remained a one-woman labor of love — free, ad-free, AI-free, and fully human: themarginalian.org/newsletter 

https://x.com/themarginalian/status/2093353695559696472

Quite a good composition and well sung by Lata Mangeshkar but it is painfully screeching in the antara. Some find reaching higher notes a great feat but music must be comforting to the ears first; appealing to the musical grammar–mind comes later. 

https://x.com/abhiertigibbet/status/2093319115369029764

https://youtu.be/7fsme4Nn6yw?si=Po8qJZeRlaUreour

Psychiatry is perhaps the only medical speciality that reads about epistemology. However, not all psychiatrists know about it because their professors don't. Reading humanities/social sciences in Psychiatry, and Postpsychiatry are more important than ever.

https://x.com/abhiertigibbet/status/2093234185867555169 

Later Austrians would develop these ideas further, but the essential stance was already present in Menger: economics is not a branch of history. It is a theoretical science that begins with the elementary facts of human choice under scarcity. 

https://x.com/CreativeDeduct/status/2093030900606906442

Introduction: Social Ruling and Solidarity in Challenged Democratic Systems

D Fridberg, P Segal - Social Ruling and Solidarity in Challenged Democratic …, 2026
… John Moolakkattu’s “Majoritarianism and the Differential Ownership of Democracy
in India” describes how a decade of Hindutva-centered governance has fractured
minority belonging and unraveled informal powersharing habits. Here, Moolakkattu …

Book review: Narender Kumar (Eds), Politics and Religion in India

S Yadav
… The Congress disseminates secularism and coordinates non-Hindu communities
for political benefits, but has also made the government collaborate with a Hindutva
political party, such as in Maharashtra. Political leaders of the Congress have also …

[PDF] Jai Shri Ram: A Brief Analysis of the Godhra Train Incident and Gujarat Riots of 2002 Deborah Scott-Harrison Sam Houston State University Word Count: 2867

D Scott-Harrison
… in American academia, exposing the findings of the American funding of Hindutva
operations, as well as contextualizing the “semiotics of terror” created in the almost
80 year-old work of VD Savarkar’s, “Hindutva.” Published almost three years after …

[PDF] Identity Construction and the Rise of Ethno-Religious Violence in India

DS Harrison
… In modern India, ethno-religious violence not only persists but is measurably
escalating coterminous to the rise of Hindutva-promulgating BJP or Bharatiya Janata
Party in Indian politics. Almost a century old, the Hindutva movement became a …

[TXT] HELSINGIN YLIOPISTO HELSINGFORS UNIVERSITET

T Kupias
… said that the BJP as well as Modi often take advantage of the Hindutva idea to reel
… Muslim Hindutva icon to many – and not least for the events described in the next
… a proponent of the Hindutva ideology, and is also a well known title attached to … ‘My God Is Modi Ji’: The Religious Representations in the Facebook Following of Narendra Modi - Teppo Kupias

[PDF] Weaponizing History: Threat to Democracy in India

A Mukherjee, M Mukherjee - Censorship and Self-Censorship in History Education
This paper discusses the current use and abuse of history in India, based on a false
colonial understanding that Hindus and Muslims constituted two antagonistic
nations and that Hindus have a deep historical memory of Muslim atrocities. The …

[PDF] “Saffronization” of the History Curriculum in India Under the BJP

A Farooq - Censorship and Self-Censorship in History Education
This essay examines the “saffronization” of history education in India under the
Bharatiya Janata Party, analyzing how curricular revisions, textbook deletions, and
popular culture together reshape historical knowledge to serve Hindu nationalist …

[PDF] Reshaping the Political Landscape: The Rise of Marginalized Sections in Contemporary Indian Politics

D Kumar
This article explores the reshaping of the political landscape in contemporary Indian
politics. How the marginalized section of the society shaped their place in the active
politics of India. Post 2014 Lok Sabha of Indian politics has undergone a significant …

[PDF] Governing Religion: Colonial Legality, State, and the Case of Hijab in India

TJ Kiliyamannil - Muslim Politics Review, 2025
In March 2022, India’s Karnataka High Court ruled that the wearing of hijab by
Muslim students was not an ‘essential religious practice’under Islam. This raised a
question of authority to interpret Islamic law, as the judges effectively decided what …

[PDF] Antinomies of Nativism: Understanding Decoloniality Theory's Affinities with the Global Far Right

A Bademsoy, N Larsen - Development and Change, 2026
This article examines the peculiar conjuncture of decolonial theory and
contemporary far‐right ideology. It argues that their shared fixation on the dualism of
native and settler is immanent to the development of advanced capitalism …

Friday, August 21, 2026

Pranab Patnaik passes away

 Collated by Tusar Nath Mohapatra

A voice that defined generations of Odia music has fallen silent. Legendary playback singer Pranab Kishore Patnaik, whose distinctive and soulful voice remained an integral part of Odisha's musical landscape for decades, passed away on Friday. His death marks the end of a golden chapter in the history of Odia music. #Odisha

https://x.com/soumyajitt/status/2090711970899181822

ନିଜର ମଧୁର କଣ୍ଠ ସ୍ଵର ଓ ଅନନ୍ୟ ଗାୟନ ଶୈଳୀରେ ଶ୍ରୋତାଙ୍କ ହୃଦୟରେ ଏକ ସ୍ୱତନ୍ତ୍ର ସ୍ଥାନ ଅର୍ଜନ କରିଥିବା ଓଡ଼ିଆ ସଙ୍ଗୀତ ଜଗତର ବର୍ଷିୟାନ କଣ୍ଠଶିଳ୍ପୀ ପ୍ରଣବ ପଟ୍ଟନାୟକଙ୍କ ବିୟୋଗରେ ଓଡ଼ିଆ ଭାଷା, ସାହିତ୍ୟ ଓ ସଂସ୍କୃତି ବିଭାଗ ତରଫରୁ ଭାବପୂର୍ଣ୍ଣ ଶ୍ରଦ୍ଧାଞ୍ଜଳି l ଓଡ଼ିଆ ସଙ୍ଗୀତ ପ୍ରତି ତାଙ୍କର ଅବଦାନ ସର୍ବଦା ଚିର ସ୍ମରଣୀୟ ହୋଇ ରହିବ।

#PranabKishorePatnaik #odiasinger #restinpeace #LegendPassesAway #culture #Odisha

https://x.com/Culturedeptt/status/2090783374831210543

ସେ ଥିଲେ ସ୍ବରର ସେହେଜାଦା। ପ୍ରେମର ସ୍ବର ପୁଣି ବିରହର ଆପଣାର। ଭକ୍ତି ହେଉ କି ଶାସ୍ତ୍ରୀୟ, ହିନ୍ଦୀ ହେଉ କି ଗଜଲ୍। ସୁଲଳିତ କଣ୍ଠରେ ଯାହା ଗାଉଥିଲେ ତାହା ହିଟ୍। ୫ ଦଶନ୍ଧି ଧରି କାଳଜୟୀ ଗୀତର ଯାଦୁଗର ଥିଲେ ପ୍ରଣବ ପଟ୍ଟନାୟକ। ‘ରୂପସୀ ରାଣୀ ଗୋ ମୋର’ଠୁ ଆରମ୍ଭ କରି ମାଝୀରେ ପର୍ଯ୍ୟନ୍ତ। ୮୮ ବର୍ଷ ବୟସରେ ସୀମା ହୀନ ଦରିଆ ଭଳି କିଭଳି ଅୟୁତ ସଫଳତାର ଉତ୍ତରାଧିକାରୀ ପ୍ରଣବ ପଟ୍ଟନାୟକଙ୍କର ଥିଲା ଲମ୍ବା କ୍ୟାରିୟର ଦେଖିବା ରିପୋର୍ଟ।...

#PranabPatnaik #PranabKishorePatnaik #OdiaMusic #OdiaCinema #Ollywood #OdiaSongs #MusicalLegacy #SpecialStory #OdishaTV #OTV

https://x.com/otvkhabar/status/2090822108842705214

ପରଲୋକରେ ପ୍ରଣବ ପଟ୍ଟନାୟକ । ଦୀର୍ଘ ଛଅ ଦଶନ୍ଧିରୁ ଅଧିକ ସମୟ ଧରି ନିଜ ମଧୁର ସ୍ୱରରେ ଅଗଣିତ ଶ୍ରୋତାଙ୍କୁ ମନ୍ତ୍ରମୁଗ୍ଧ କରିଥିବା ପ୍ରଣବଙ୍କ ଅପାସୋରା ଗୀତ ଆଜି ସ୍ମୃତିରେ ଗୁଞ୍ଜରିତ ହେଉଛି । ଏହି କାଳଜୟୀ କଣ୍ଠଶିଳ୍ପୀଙ୍କ ସଙ୍ଗୀତ ଯାତ୍ରାର କାହାଣୀ ନେଇ ଦୂରଦର୍ଶନର ସ୍ୱତନ୍ତ୍ର ଉପସ୍ଥାପନା.... #PranabPattnaik #Odisha #LegendarySinger

https://x.com/DDNewsOdia/status/2090808592412925952

This is a self goal. Given time ignorant fanatics amongst Abhrahamic and leftists will demand the same for those songs as well. One argument to make would be that in Indian culture and literary tradition we personify nation, language and rivers as Mother and adore them.

https://x.com/Shiva_Uvacha/status/2090729800877146245

Between Fluency and Belonging: English and the Learners Left Behind

by Sanjoe P Davis countercurrents.org/2026/08/betwee…

India’s English education system has long focused on grammar, comprehension and written performance, while giving little attention to whether learners experience English as a language they can genuinely use and claim as their own. This article examines the gap between examination-based proficiency and meaningful language use, drawing on research into language, identity, class and caste. It explores the idea of “language investment” and proposes Language Identity and Agency as a dimension of English assessment. The article argues for an approach that recognises oral communication, self-expression and learners’ relationships with English alongside conventional measures of grammatical accuracy and written competence.

https://x.com/Countercurrents/status/2090760479534883155

Why @BJP4India Must Recover Its Soft Power: Time for the party to learn from the subversive genius of Mahatma Gandhi 

openthemagazine.com/politics/bjp-m… @psitsgayatri @TVMohandasPai @sriaurobindochr @sriaurobindofdn @PariksithSingh @Openthemag @prasannara @narendramodi @narendramodi_in

https://x.com/MakrandParanspe/status/2090758014320115771

Gandhi Propagated the Varna System in Northeast India through Hindi: Mohandas Naimishray

by Rajashree Saikia and Ajit Kumar countercurrents.org/2026/08/gandhi…

Mohandas Naimishray discusses the history and contemporary state of Dalit literature, social justice and Ambedkarite thought in Northeast India in a conversation with Rajashree Saikia and Ajit Kumar. He argues that the promotion of Hindi during Gandhi’s visits to the region also carried Hindu religious practices, customs and the varna system, while Ambedkar’s ideas had limited institutional and literary presence. Naimishray calls for greater access to Ambedkar’s writings, Dalit literary conferences and stronger Ambedkarite engagement across the Northeast. The conversation also explores his understanding of hissedari, the relationship between literature and politics, Buddhism, caste discrimination and the continuing development of Dalit literature.

https://x.com/Countercurrents/status/2090756657513160803

What we’re seeing here is the otherwise quite conservative and traditionalist scholar of the #dharmashastra PV Kane throwing his support behind the efforts of #ambedkar with respect to the super-controversial Hindu Code Bill. 

Ambedkar cited Kane extensively (albeit critically) and Kane also read Ambedkar’s “The Buddha and His Dhamma” and referenced it. I’m trying to learn more about their relationship, especially the overlapping time they spent together in the Rajya Sabha.

https://x.com/ASR_Metta/status/2090764954475417856

Barbarians at the Gate — When Greed Takes the Driver’s Seat By Bryan Burrough and John Helyar

The more uncomfortable interpretation is that the greatest threat may come from inside the organisation itself—when executives, boards and financiers begin treating a company primarily as a vehicle for personal wealth, prestige and power. That makes the book much more than a story about an old takeover. It becomes a study of corporate greed and human nature. When numbers conceal human behaviour

https://x.com/shrikant_soman/status/2090774327843225705

Down with Upper Respiratory Tract Infection—sore throat, sinusitis, running nose, earache—mostly viral. Never do I get the urge to sing more than these days when I have a blocked nose and sore throat.

https://x.com/abhiertigibbet/status/2090776582520529234

#NewPublication Atlas of Medieval and Renaissance Thought, Philosophy and Science Overviews and Surveys in the Form of Charts, Tables and Conceptual Maps Thomas H. Brobjer, Routledge, 2026 Preview PDF taylorfrancis.com/books/mono/10.…

https://x.com/khalidsyossef/status/2090473700571144413

Galileo claimed “mathematics is the language in which the book of nature is written”, and no more is this apparent than in quantum field theory. bit.ly/4n1z5lP But Timothy Nguyen argues predictive success along is not enough for a fundamental theory of reality.

https://x.com/IAI_TV/status/2090824752055144620

Gravity is simultaneously familiar and mysterious. | bit.ly/3U8HHxo Physicist Melvin Vopson argues for a controversial view of gravity, arguing information is as fundamental as mass and energy, and gravity is a way for the universe to minimize the complexity of information.

https://x.com/IAI_TV/status/2090404502729818544

Identity, Development and Governance

J Mukherjee - The 2024 Parliamentary Elections in India: Nation …, 2026
… electoral politics, caste politics has taken a new turn towards subaltern Hindutva.
3 There has been a transformative shift over the years … The 2009 manifesto of the
BJP appears to present a more liberal secular outlook of the BJP far removed from …

[PDF] Mapping Media Bias: Global Islamophobic Trends and their Reflections in South Asia

N Shahid, B Ghazanfar - The Beacon Journal, 2025
… This type of negative media coverage relies heavily on the ‘us-vs-them’ framework,
which stigmatises the Muslim communities and reinforces the Hindutva narrative that
the very presence of Muslims in India is an abhorration to what constitutes an Indian …

Indian National Congress in the 2024 Lok Sabha Election: Nation, Religion, and Identity

R Saxena - The 2024 Parliamentary Elections in India: Nation …, 2026
… without completely abandoning the BJP’s Hindutva ideology. The Congress had
to uphold its … and its attempt to counter the BJP's Hindutva rhetoric while
simultaneously appealing to a wide … But the emergence of Hindutva politics …

[PDF] Mandir vs Mandal in 2024: are there limits to the BJP's social engineering?

S Chaturvedi, DN Gellner, SK Pandey - Contemporary South Asia, 2026
… The BJP’s strategy for winning in UP depends on a combination of its core Hindu
nationalist (Hindutva) message with ‘social engineering’, ie, seeking to include
formerly subordinate social groups, politically, socially, and economically, within the …

BJP's Fortuitous Victory in Odisha's 2024 General Elections

P Sarangi - The 2024 Parliamentary Elections in India: Nation …, 2026
… The ideology and politics of Hindutva in Odisha could be traced back to the pre-independence
years and was discernible in every sphere … This [new] political process marks a
clear contrast against subaltern Hindutva that patronisingly implies the co-optation of …

Hindutva Checkmated? Interplay of Religion, Caste and Identity in the 2024 Lok Sabha Election in West Bengal

H Bhattacharyya, P Ganguly - The 2024 Parliamentary Elections in India: Nation …, 2026
Since its outstanding electoral performance in 2019 Lok Sabha elections in West
Bengal, the electoral fortunes of the BJP dwindled although it maintained a
competitive share of popular votes to that of the ruling TMC. In 2024 Lok Sabha …

[PDF] The Curious Case of Dadagiri: Masculinities and Everyday Power in the Ghats of Kolkata

R Ghosh - Journal für Entwicklungspolitik, 2025
While masculinity has often been read as a conscious projection of identity, a
performance or a “configuration of praxis” to practice “hegemony, subordination,
complicity or marginalisation” (Connell 1995, 2016), this paper showcases how …

Religion, Region and Immigrants: Decoding the BJP Victory in Assam in 2024 Lok Sabha Elections

S Nag - The 2024 Parliamentary Elections in India: Nation …, 2026
… allure of Hindutva in Assam. It is noteworthy that, despite a century-long struggle
of Assamese Hindus against Muslim immigration, Hindutva has … In 2024, the BJP’s
victory was attributable not to the ascendance of Hindutva, but rather to the …

Religion, Caste and Contingency: Electoral Politics in UP

S Pai - The 2024 Parliamentary Elections in India: Nation …, 2026
… This chapter examines the strident contest between the newly formed INDIA
Alliance (IA) and the BJP-led NDA, on Hindutva versus democracy in the 2024
general elections and why it could not be sustained, despite the former making a …

Hindus and their Christian Interlocutors

J Lunstroth - Fratelli Tutti in Conversation
… I made an argument in my last paper in this book series that Hinduism is now
synonymous with Hindutva, the conservative Indian political … In Hindutva religion
and politics are merged, in imitation of the Christian ideal, and the Catholic actuality …