Sri Aurobindo challenges the perceived supremacy of Western rationality

 The basic prejudices against Sri Aurobindo in the West stem primarily from a long-standing intellectual tradition that prioritizes materialism, empirical science, and analytical reason over subjective spiritual experience, metaphysics, and mysticism. 

Here are the underlying prejudices that often lead to the dismissal of his work:

• Materialism vs. Spirituality: Western thought, particularly in academic philosophy and politics, tends to have a materialistic or secular foundation. Sri Aurobindo's emphasis on a pervasive "Spirit" (Brahman) as the sole reality, and the goal of a complete spiritual transformation of earthly life, is fundamentally at odds with this worldview.
• Rationality as the Sole Arbiter of Truth: There is a strong bias in the West towards knowledge verifiable through the rational mind and sensory experience. Sri Aurobindo argues that human reason is imperfect and limited in scope, and that true knowledge (integral knowledge) comes from a higher, suprarational consciousness. This challenges the perceived supremacy of Western rationality.
• "Mysticism" as Anti-Intellectual: The term "mysticism" in the West often carries a connotation of being vague, irrational, or unscientific. Sri Aurobindo's ideas are often quickly categorized this way, allowing them to be dismissed without serious philosophical engagement, as they fall outside the established boundaries of what is considered "legitimate" philosophy.
• Post-Colonial and Orientalist Bias: A lingering post-colonial bias sometimes influences the reception of Indian philosophy in the West. Indian philosophical traditions were historically devalued during the colonial era as "steeped in religion" and lacking true intellectual rigor compared to Western secular philosophy. This historical prejudice can affect the current academic reception of thinkers like Sri Aurobindo.
• Critique of Western Systems: Sri Aurobindo was a significant critic of Western political and social systems, which he saw as mechanistic, materialistic, and leading to social fragmentation. This critique, which proposes a non-Western, spiritually informed model of governance and development, can be viewed as incompatible or idealistic from within Western secular frameworks.
• Utopianism vs. Pragmatism: The vision of an "ideal human unity" achieved through a radical spiritual evolution is often dismissed as utopian and impractical. Critics argue that such a profound shift in human consciousness is unachievable in the face of immediate crises and entrenched power structures, lacking concrete strategies for short-term problems. 

These prejudices form a cultural and intellectual barrier, causing his sophisticated and logical framework to be characterized simply as "mystical" and overlooked by mainstream Western discourse. - GoogleAI

Engaging Religio-Cultural Nationalism

S Thompson - The Other Lutherans: Voices from the Global South, 2026

Why is an Evangelical Catholic Witness of Justification Important for the Global South?

AL García - The Other Lutherans: Voices from the Global South, 2026

Transdiasporic Indo-Caribbean Anthologies and Post-Amnesia Jahaji Bhai (n)

J Bhai - The Asian Caribbean in the Caribbean Diaspora …, 2026

[PDF] From Assimilation to Resistance: Body, Identity and Intersectionality in Ghoul (2018)

B Sinha, A Dirghangi - AM Journal of Art and Media Studies, 2025

This paper critically examines the intersections of gender, religion, and social politics through the character of Nida Rahim in the Indian Netflix miniseries Ghoul (2018). Through the protagonist, it analyzes a struggle for bodily autonomy and identity in a …

Secularization, Social Order, and World History: Toward a Global Perspective

KN Flatt - 2025

… But global varieties of secular order encountered resistance in the latter part of the twentieth century, from the spread of the Muslim Brotherhood to the Iranian Revolution, and from the rising power of Hindutva in India to the renaissance of …

[HTML] Harsh Mander: The incomplete dream of constitutional socialism in free India

H Mander - 2025

… The result is that democracy, socialism, egalitarianism, federalism and secularism are all sacrificed on the later of the march of Hindutva and the interests of chosen crony capitalists. Without formally repudiating the constitution, the Hindutva- crony …

Why the Adivasi Will Not Dance

P Chakravorty

The title of this chapter is inspired by Hansda Sowvendra Shekhar’s book The Adivasi Will Not Dance: Stories (2015). He is an Adivasi author writing in English about the lives, cultures, and values of Adivasi life. 1 Although the author was writing …

[PDF] TASK FORCE ON ACADEMIC FREEDOM AND TENURE

MJ Dutta, A Brekke, T Discenna, TM Harris, K Johnson…

… Along these lines, academics challenging the Indian state’s implementation of the Hindutva ideology have faced attacks on their academic freedom, with their mobilities to India targeted. Collaborators of scholars internationally are targeted …

INHABITING THE IN-BETWEEN

V IYENGAR

… And given that the nature, history, and form of kathak make it extremely difficult and messy to co-opt into a majoritarian and narrow Hindutva narrative, are we looking toward a future where kathak itself will be estranged—excommunicated …

[PDF] CoVe in Indonesia: A Case Study of Composite Violent Extremism

AI Soemitro, M Syauqillah, IMW Wardhana - … Journal on Culture, History, and Religion, 2025

… Then, the prolonged Palestine-Kashmir conflict gave rise to the potential for convergence between ethnoreligious ideologies and aggressive nationalism, namely Zionism and Hindutva. The narrative of fear of Islam and past grievances is …

Collated by Tusar Nath Mohapatra

Faustus, Don Juan, and Zorba

 Collated by Tusar Nath Mohapatra

Yes, Don Juan and Zorba can be effectively contrasted with Faustus based on their core pursuits and approaches to life. While Faustus seeks transcendent knowledge, power, and the supernatural, Don Juan and Zorba are driven by immanent, worldly experiences and sensuality [1]. 

Faustus: The Seeker of Transcendence

Christopher Marlowe's Doctor Faustus is a tragic figure defined by his ambition to exceed the limits of human knowledge and power. 

• Core Desire: He craves forbidden knowledge, magical power, and control over the elements and spirits. He feels constrained by the boundaries of traditional scholarship (logic, medicine, divinity).
• Method: He forms a pact with the devil (Mephistopheles), selling his soul in exchange for a finite period of omnipotence and knowledge.
• Outcome: His pursuit leads to damnation and a tragic end, highlighting the dangers of pride and overstepping natural human boundaries. 

Don Juan: The Seeker of Worldly Sensation

Don Juan (appearing in various works like Molière's play or Mozart's opera Don Giovanni) is a libertine whose existence is rooted in immediate sensory experience. 

• Core Desire: He seeks pleasure, specifically in the seduction and conquest of women. His goal is not the accumulation of power or abstract knowledge, but the immediate, tangible experience of life and desire.
• Method: He is a master of disguise and deception, using his charm and wit to achieve his carnal goals. He lives entirely in the moment, unburdened by guilt or consideration for the future.
• Outcome: He often meets a dramatic, supernatural end (e.g., dragged to hell by a stone statue), but his life is a celebration of sensuality and defiance of moral constraints, unlike Faustus's desperate pursuit of the abstract. 

Zorba: The Seeker of Life's Fullness

Nikos Kazantzakis's Zorba the Greek presents a character whose philosophy is a vibrant embrace of life, unmediated by intellect or spiritual ambition. 

• Core Desire: Zorba is a man who lives with complete abandon, prioritizing dance, music, and honest human connection. He seeks to experience life in its entirety, rather than merely understand it.
• Method: He operates on instinct, passion, and a deep appreciation for the simple joys of the world. He views intellectualism and excessive planning as barriers to true living.
• Outcome: He is a resilient, life-affirming character who teaches the narrator the value of letting go and experiencing joy despite life's inevitable suffering. 

The Contrast

The fundamental difference lies in their focus:

Character	Focus	Pursuit	Outcome
Faustus	Metaphysical	Forbidden Knowledge & Power	Damnation/Tragedy
Don Juan	Physical/Sensory	Pleasure & Seduction	Defiance/Judgment
Zorba	Existential	Fullness of Experience	Life-Affirming/Wisdom

Faustus looks upward and outward for power, while Don Juan and Zorba look inward and around them for lived experience. The former wants to transcend humanity; the latter two want to fully, passionately, be human. 

- GoogleAI 

https://www.google.com/search?q=Can+Don+Juan+or+Zorba+be+contrasted+with+Faustus&client

Pecking order and cooperative breeding

 Collated by Tusar Nath Mohapatra

Sociology learns from the study of birds in several key areas related to social behavior and culture, including the origins of social structures, cooperation, communication, and cultural evolution in non-human societies. 

Key insights include:

• Social Learning and Culture: Birds provide excellent models for understanding how behaviors are acquired and transmitted through social learning, leading to the formation of "cultures" or local traditions. This has been extensively studied in contexts such as:
  • Song dialects: The development of distinct regional songs in passerines (songbirds) demonstrates cultural transmission across generations, similar to human language variations.
  • Foraging techniques and tool use: Innovations in foraging behaviors, like New Caledonian crows using tools or tits learning to open milk bottles, can spread through a population's social network, illustrating how culture can help species adapt to changing environments.
  • Predator recognition: Naive birds can learn to identify predators by observing the alarm responses of experienced group members, showing the social transmission of vital knowledge.
  • Migration routes: In some long-lived species like geese and cranes, migration routes are culturally inherited, passed down from experienced older birds to juveniles, which can help populations respond to climate change or other environmental shifts.
• Social Structures and Cooperation: Studying how birds interact offers insights into general principles of social organization:
  • Dominance hierarchies: The concept of the "pecking order" (pecking order in hens), a classic example of a dominance hierarchy, provides a simple model for understanding rank and status in social groups.
  • Cooperative breeding and altruism: Many bird species engage in cooperative breeding, where "helpers" assist a primary breeding pair in raising offspring. This behavior helps sociologists and biologists study the evolution of altruism and the role of kinship and social bonds in cooperation.
  • Social Bonds: Birds form complex, individualized relationships and long-term social bonds, which play a key role in cooperation, conflict resolution, and group stability, similar to dynamics in many social mammals, including primates and humans.
• Methodological Applications: Avian studies are used as powerful experimental systems to test fundamental theories in behavioral ecology and social science because their behaviors are highly visible and can be studied both in the lab and field. The ease of tracking individual birds in large populations with modern technology allows researchers to gather large-scale data on social dynamics and collective decision-making, offering unique windows into the ecology of collective behavior that can be used to understand similar phenomena in humans. 

Ultimately, bird studies help sociology and related fields by providing comparative models for the origins and functions of social complexity, illuminating the interplay between individual behavior, social interaction, and environmental factors across different species, including our own. 

- GoogleAI 

https://www.google.com/search?q=What+does+sociology+learn+from+the+birds

[PDF] LINGUISTICS IN BIHAR

A Kumar, H District-Begusarai

… Before English media began blatantly supporting the Hindutva forces and major Hindi publications had already caved in. … Besides consuming a considerable energy of Hindi speakers, the resentment fuels the Hindutva’s flawed contention of ‘the …

[PDF] Political Populism and the Media

MS Pinto - 2026

… He put this supreme talent to very good use for divisive politics in polarising masses with his Hindutva ideology, casting communal innuendos … The key difference appears to be that Modi is striving to govern through a hardcore Hindutva …

South Asia's Freedom in Global Perspective: Nation, Partition, Federation

S Bose, A Jalal - 2025

This book engages in a creative process of historical retrieval of visions for substantive democracy and federal union during the struggle for freedom that remained unrealized during the post-colonial transition. Structured in three parts, the …

சீதாயணம் புதினத்தில் சாதி என்னும் கருத்தாக்கம்: Conceptualization of the caste in Seethayanam Novel

G Satheeswaran - Tamilmanam International Research Journal of Tamil …, 2025

Human societies are sustained through shared cultural narratives, among which myths and literature play a crucial role in shaping and regulating collective life. These narratives often function to legitimize and reinforce the ideologies of the ruling …

Show the Guru Cheating: Ekalavya re-tellings in post-Independent India's Hindi heartlands

C Sharma - Journal of Hindu Studies, 2025

Ekalavya has emerged as a significant figure in Mahabharata re-tellings in post-Independent India. In the wildly popular 1980s television serial, Mahabharat, the Ekalavya story arc appears as a crucial and troubling depiction of the violence of the caste system …

[PDF] Rethinking Knowledge, Unthinking the Brahminical: Dalit Feminism and Gender-Caste

U Geetha - CASTE/A Global Journal on Social Exclusion, 2025

This article introduces a Dalit decolonial feminist standpoint as an epistemic and political framework that redefines feminist thought through four interrelated pillars. It argues that decolonial and postcolonial frameworks remain constrained by their …